Today the Obama administration announced that trials of five people accused of participation in the 9/11 attacks will be held in New York City in Federal Court. It was also announced that five other Guantanamo detainees will be tried by a military court for their part in the attack on the USS Cole. It’s about time. The Bush administration did nothing during eight years in office to mete out justice to these individuals. Instead they have all been held without trial at the Guantanamo prison camp in Cuba. One can only wonder at the thought processes of the people in the Bush administration.
Guilt and innocence are black and white. A person has either committed a crime or they haven’t. The government either has proof of their guilt or it doesn’t.
Predictably, the extreme right wing of American politics, i.e. the Republicans are upset about the Obama administration’s plans to conduct a trial in New York City. It seems that these people would prefer a hanging without a trial. Or, as they shout loudly, they would prefer a military trial where the defendants won’t have the same rights to a fair trial that Americans enjoy. And then, of course there is the Republican “concern” about putting these people in American prisons if they are found guilty. It seems that they feel that American prisons are not too dependable. What if these people escaped? So, these confused Republicans like the idea of keeping them in a makeshift prison camp in Cuba where they seem to feel escape is impossible instead of a maximum security prison in the U.S. from which no one has ever escaped.
The holding of trials in New York City is exactly what should be done. NYC is the scene of the crime. The people of New York City, who will be the jurors in these cases, will have the opportunity themselves to determine the guilt or innocence of each defendant. This is the epitome of American justice. So what are Senators Cornyn, Smith, McCain and Lieberman worried about? (I know that Lieberman is not a Republican, but he might as well be and give up the sham of pretending to be an Independent.) Do they think our system of justice is inferior to the military system? Really? Is that what United States Senators think these days? Do they think that maybe these people won’t be convicted because the evidence is not compelling enough? Well…. isn’t that what a trial is all about?
Let’s suppose that in the case of one of these individuals that the government doesn’t actually have any proof that this person committed the crime of which they are accused. Let’s say that maybe the government only has a strong suspicion and maybe some hearsay evidence that no court would admit as evidence. So maybe they get found innocent. What is wrong with that? A person is either guilty or innocent. You either have the proof or you don’t. If you don’t have the proof how can you put someone to death? Are the Republicans looking to hold fair trails or would they just prefer a witch hunt where you judge the person guilty without evidence and then you just kill him. Is that the Republican concept of justice?
Let’s suppose that one of these people is put on trial and the jury finds them innocent because the government has no proof that they are guilty. What should be done? Should we kill them anyway or should they be set free? My guess is that these Republican Senators would prefer the “kill him anyway” approach. This is how far the Republican Party, in all its paranoia, has drifted away from truth, logic, justice, and American ideals. We cannot be afraid of holding a fair trial even for Osama bin Laden if he is captured. Facts are facts. Truth is truth. We either have the evidence or we don’t. If we don’t have the evidence, how can we pronounce anyone guilty of anything?
It is my guess that the government has a massive amount of evidence against each of these individuals. It is my guess that they will all be found guilty and be sentenced to death. Why are these Republicans so upset? Do they have no faith in American justice or would rather not have justice at all? Should we just hang them all because they look guilty or because they are Muslims? Could it be that the only “proof” we have is from confessions made during waterboarding torture sessions?
Whatever the worries of the ultra-right wing Republican Party, there is no excuse for not providing American justice for these people. Anything else is a vote of no confidence in our democracy. It is a vote of no confidence in our system of justice. It is a vote of no confidence in the ability of ordinary Americans to be part of a jury and come to the correct decisions.
The thing I don’t understand is this: how can these U.S. Senators say these outrageous insults about our American system of justice and then still call themselves Americans? Perhaps they need to resign from the Senate and let some true believers in American ideals take their place.
