Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Posts Tagged ‘death panels’

As the Senate prepares to take up the issue of health care reform, the Republican Party is gearing up for a fight to the finish, a fight to defeat any attempt at improving our health care system.  It is a desperate struggle the Republicans are waging, desperate because it is about money – lots of money.  It’s also a sad struggle because it shows so clearly how corrupt our government is. Granted, our government has been corrupt for a long time. Slipping a wad of money into a Congressman’s pocket is an old tradition on Capitol Hill. It’s the best way to assure that you can either get the legislation you want or to prevent legislation you don’t want from being passed.  Today, this “passing of bucks” is accomplished by middlemen, called lobbyists. It seems that just about every Congressman and Senator has his price. There are precious few who cannot be bought.

Money is where the health industry comes in. It is, of course where Republicans come in as well.  After all, they are the Party of business, of Capitalism, of profit. That is their constituency.  One is tempted to say, “OK, that’s alright. Let the Republicans represent the sellers of goods and the Democrats represent the buyers of goods.” Of course, it’s not that simple because the Democrats also represent the ordinary workers, while the Republicans represent the employers.  But one would hope at least that there could be an honest debate.  One could hope that there would be a rational discussion of the facts – all in the national interest.  It would be a debate about what is best for the American people – after all, isn’t that ultimately the purpose of Congress – to do what is best for Americans?

Unfortunately, the Republican Party has chosen not to have a debate on the merits of health care reform.  Instead they have launched campaigns of outright lies about reform. They have tried mightily to steer the debate into discussions about Death Panels and Nazi medical experiments and the rationing of health care.  Any reasonable person can tell that these Republican tactics are nothing but lies and because they are lies and not real issues that should be discussed, the Republican Party has done a disservice to America – in brief, they have become un-American in their zeal to protect the profitability of medicine.

There is a danger here in all of this distortion, in all of these attempts to steer the discussion away from the real issues and to focus on trumped-up concerns that have no basis in reality.  The danger is that we will fail to ever discuss the actual dangers that are inherent in our current way of going about the health business.  Here is one excellent example that, as far as I can tell, is being completely ignored: we have a vastly insufficient supply of H1N1 vaccine because we have a for-profit health system.

The simple fact is that not everyone gets a flu shot every year. Most people do not get routine flu shots and because of this our vaccine industry, ever intent on making a profit, has sized itself according to the yearly demand for flu shots.  Our commercial vaccine production industry simply does not have the capability of making enough H1N1 vaccine to protect everyone man, woman, and child in this country. It simply cannot be done.

So, I would ask our imaginative friends in the Republican Party, the ones whose vivid imaginations can conjure up images of Death Panels and Nazi medicine being practiced on Americans, and the limiting of health care to only those who are connected with someone in government, to think about something else. Consider this: suppose the H1N1 flu strain that is making the rounds this year was different. Suppose instead that it was the same H1N1 strain that made the rounds in 1918. How many people would die in America? One hundred million? Two hundred million? How many would die in the entire world? A billion? Two billion? What could be done stop that strain of flu?  Nothing. Nothing could be done in 1918 and nothing could be done now.

The question I would put to the Republican members of Congress is this: is there any way you could think of that we might be able to make enough vaccine for everyone in a case like this?  There is only one answer: the government has to create this capability in advance – it’s not a last-minute sort of thing.  Why? Because it’s a money loser. Big business would hate it – it’s a gigantic capacity that would only be used once in a lifetime.  You can’t make money from that. Which is why there is a natural role for government in health care. The government spends about half of our national budget on defense – i.e. defending us from other people in other countries. How long will it take until we understand that it is also the role of government to defend us from other foreign attackers, things like viruses and bacteria. It might seem strange at first to look at it that way, but think about this: suppose – just suppose – that there really were aliens from Mars attacking us – would it be the role of government to defend us? What if instead of the Martians being little green men they were little green bugs?  What if these little green bugs were actually microscopic invaders? How is that different from deadly Earth-based viruses attacking us?

The simple fact is that the government has a duty to protect its citizens. This duty extends to protecting the citizen’s health. Health care should not be a profit-making business.  It should be more like a utility, available to everyone and dispensed by the government. That doesn’t mean that businesses can’t play. People are certainly free to purchase health related things, but the government has to understand that it has a responsibility for the health of its citizens – a responsibility that cannot be dodged and delegated to the profit-making business community.  We missed a bullet this time with the H1N1 flu; however, it is virtually certain that a time will come in the future when a very deadly viral pandemic will sweep over the Earth.  The steps our Congress takes in the next couple of months may well determine whether America survives that inevitable pandemic; it may well determine whether the population of our country is obliterated or if it survives.  It would be a shame if hundreds of millions of Americans died in the future all because the Republicans wanted to help their friends in the health business make a buck.

Read Full Post »

%d bloggers like this: